PTO and Sick Time Combined: A Must-Know Guide for Employers

As employers look for ways to simplify leave management and encourage employees to take time off when they need it, many are shifting to a combined paid time off (PTO) policy. This single bank for PTO and sick time combines vacation time, personal days, and paid sick leave into one, giving employees a certain amount of paid leave hours to use as they see fit.

In this guide, we’ll dive into benefits, challenges and compliance tips to consider when setting up combined PTO and paid sick leave policies that truly work for both employees and the company.

Why combine PTO and sick time?

Combining PTO and sick time into a single paid time off (PTO) policy can simplify things for both employees and employers, bringing flexibility, efficiency, and even cultural benefits to the workplace.

Benefits for employees

A combined PTO policy empowers employees by giving them more flexibility. Rather than worrying about how many sick days, personal days, or vacation days they have left, employees get a single bank of paid leave hours that they can use as they need. Here’s how it benefits employees:

• More flexibility: Employees can use their combined PTO for personal time, paid sick leave, mental health days, or vacation time, all from the same bank, without needing to justify why they’re taking the day off.

• Less stress over sick time: With a combined policy, employees don’t have to worry about whether they have enough sick leave or paid sick time for unexpected illnesses. They’re simply using their available PTO.

• Enhanced satisfaction: Having control over how and when to use paid time off (PTO) generally increases job satisfaction and contributes to a healthier work-life balance.

Streamlined administration for employers

For employers, combining vacation and sick time can reduce the administrative load of tracking multiple types of employee leave. Here’s what that looks like:

• Simplified tracking: Instead of tracking vacation policies, paid sick leave policies, and personal days separately, employers only need to manage one PTO policy. This reduces paperwork and makes it easier to track employee time and leave hours.

• Consistency across the board: Combined PTO creates consistency in how paid leave is managed across departments, helping HR manage employee leaves more effectively.

• Fewer compliance issues: A single policy for sick and vacation time can reduce confusion around state laws and paid sick leave policies, as there’s only one set of rules to follow. This can make it easier for employers to ensure they’re compliant with paid sick leave laws and paid leave requirements.

Key considerations before implementing combined PTO

Before rolling out a combined PTO policy, employers need to consider how this change might affect the workplace culture, finances, and legal compliance.

Impact on company culture

A combined PTO policy can foster a sense of trust and autonomy. Here’s how:

• Builds trust: Allowing employees to decide when to take time off, whether for sick days or vacation time, shows that the company trusts them to manage their own leave.

• Increases autonomy: Employees feel more in control of their time, which can lead to a boost in morale andproductivity. When employers encourage employees to use their time off freely, it can improve overall satisfaction.

• Supports mental health: With more flexibility, employees are more likely to take days off for mental health or personal reasons, reducing burnout and promoting a supportive culture.

Financial implications and liability

When combining vacation and paid sick leave, it’s essential to consider how unused PTO will be managed, especially when employees leave the company:

• Handling unused sick time and PTO upon termination: In many states, employers are legally required to pay out unused vacation time but may not be required to do the same for paid sick leave. Combining vacation and sick time into one bank means that any unused time may need to be paid out upon termination, depending on state laws.

• Potential costs: Paying out unused PTO can increase financial liability, particularly for companies in states that require employers to provide this compensation. Balancing the right amount of combined PTO is key to minimizing financial strain on the company.

• Impact on payroll: Combined PTO can affect payroll management since tracking and paying out a single bank of PTO hours differs from tracking separate sick and vacation policies.

Legal and compliance requirements

Navigating legal requirements is a big part of setting up a combined PTO policy. Here’s what employers should know:

• State laws and federal law compliance: Laws pertaining to paid sick leave vary across states, with some requiring specific amounts of sick time that cannot be rolled over or combined with other types of leave. For example, California, New York, and Massachusetts have strict sick leave laws that companies must comply with.

• Paid sick leave laws: Some states mandate that paid sick time be tracked separately from other types of leave. Employers need to understand the sick leave laws in their state before combining vacation and sick leave to avoid compliance issues.

• Developing a compliance strategy: To ensure legal compliance, companies may need to work closely with HR and legal professionals. Setting up a transparent PTO policy that meets state minimum requirements and federal regulations can help employers avoid costly penalties.

Potential challenges of combined PTO

Despite the benefits, there are challenges with a combined PTO policy that employers need to be mindful of to ensure it’s effective.

Risk of PTO depletion

A common concern with combined PTO is that employees might use up their available hours early in the year, leaving themselves with no paid time for unexpected illnesses later. Here’s why that can be an issue:

• No safety net for unexpected illnesses: Employees who burn through their PTO early for vacation or personal time may find themselves without enough leave for unexpected sick days. This can leave them in a tough spot, forced to either work while sick or take unpaid leave.

• Balancing paid and unpaid leave: Employers should consider providing guidance on spreading out PTO, or offering an option for employees to bank additional unpaid leave hours to cover unexpected needs.

Balancing vacation and sick needs

Balancing vacation and sick time in a single PTO policy can be challenging, especially when employees have varying needs. Here’s how to handle it:

• Setting realistic PTO limits: Offering a fair amount of PTO to cover both vacation and sick days is key. Companies should consider industry standards and employee needs when setting these limits to prevent employees from feeling short-changed.

• Clear PTO policy guidance: Providing guidelines on PTO usage and encouraging employees to plan their time can help prevent situations where employees run out of time off for unexpected illnesses.

Alternatives to combining PTO and sick time

For companies that want flexibility without fully merging vacation and sick time, alternative models might be the answer.

Hybrid models with optional sick leave

A hybrid model offers the benefits of flexible PTO while still preserving a separate bank for sick days. Here’s how it works:

• Flexible PTO with dedicated paid sick leave: Employees have a general PTO bank for vacation and personal days, along with separate sick leave. This allows companies to meet legal paid sick leave requirements without reducing available vacation days.

• Encourages employees to use sick days appropriately: With this model, employees can take sick days when needed without feeling like they’re cutting into their vacation time. It also reduces the risk of PTO depletion, as some leave is reserved for illness.

Unlimited PTO policies

The trend of unlimited PTO is gaining popularity, particularly in startups and tech companies. Here’s how it impacts traditional PTO models:

• Flexibility without caps: Employees can take time off as they need without worrying about running out of leave hours. This can improve mental health and work-life balance.

• Challenges with accountability: While unlimited PTO can increase satisfaction, companies may struggle withtracking employee leaves. Having clear guidelines ensures that employees don’t feel pressured to work while sick or skip vacation.

Manage leave and absence with ease!

• Automatic accrual of vacation hours
• Request leave easily
• Leave registrations visible in the planning

Try for free Request a demo

Simplify PTO management with Shiftbase

Implementing a combined PTO policy is easier with the right tools. Shiftbase offers comprehensive employee scheduling, time tracking, and absence management features that streamline your PTO and sick time policies. With Shiftbase, tracking employee leave and ensuring compliance with state and federal laws becomes hassle-free. Our software not only helps you manage PTO efficiently but also supports better planning and flexibility for both employers and employees.

Ready to simplify your PTO policy? Try Shiftbase for free for 14 days and experience how workforce management can be smooth and straightforward!