Reviving Underperforming Employees: A Strategic Guide

What is meant by underperforming employees?

Underperforming employees are individuals within a team who consistently fail to meet performance goals and expectations set by their role or the organization. Their performance issues may be influenced by various factors, including personal life challenges, inadequate skill sets, lack of motivation, or mismatches between the employee and their current role.

Addressing underperformance effectively involves understanding the root cause and providing appropriate support and guidance to help these team members improve their performance.

Common reasons for underperformance

• Work Environment: A toxic or unsupportive work environment can hinder employee performance and motivation.

• Lack of Employee Feedback: Without regular feedback and constructive criticism, employees may not understand their performance expectations.

• Unrealistic Expectations: Setting overly ambitious goals can demotivate employees, leading to low performance.

• Personal Issues: Personal challenges can significantly impact an employee's performance at work.

• Skills Gap: Employees may struggle if they lack the necessary skills or haven't received adequate training.

• Poor Work-Life Balance: When employees are overwhelmed with work, their performance may suffer.

• Mismatched Role: Placing the right person in the wrong role can lead to consistent underperformance.

• External Factors: External factors like market changes or technological advancements can affect an employee's ability to meet expectations.

How to identify underperformance at the workplace?

To identify underperforming employees, managers should look for signs like consistently missing performance standards, failing to meet expectations, displaying a lack of interest, or delivering poor-quality work.

Regular one-on-one meetings can be a valuable tool to check progress, discuss performance issues, and understand any underlying challenges. Encouraging open communication and providing positive feedback can help uncover the root causes of underperformance, whether they stem from personal issues, a lack of skills, or other work-related factors.

In some cases, additional training or support may be required to help employees improve their performance and succeed in their roles.

Remember, managing underperforming employees requires a consistent and compassionate approach. While termination processes may be necessary in extreme cases, the focus should always be on understanding the root cause of underperformance and providing opportunities for growth and improvement.

By creating a supportive and understanding work environment, organizations can help employees overcome challenges and flourish in their roles.

How HR can deal with underperformance?

1. Creating a supportive work environment

A supportive work environment plays a crucial role in addressing underperformance effectively. When employees feel valued, understood, and motivated, they are more likely to overcome challenges and improve their performance. HR can take specific steps to foster such an environment.

• Encourage Open Communication: HR should promote open channels of communication where employees can express their concerns, seek help, and share feedback without fear of judgment. Regular team meetings and one-on-one sessions can facilitate this exchange.

• Provide Constructive Feedback: Offer specific, actionable feedback to underperforming employees. Instead of merely pointing out flaws, focus on strengths and areas for improvement, ensuring the feedback is encouraging and supportive.

• Recognize and Celebrate Achievements: Acknowledge employees' progress and accomplishments, no matter how small. Celebrating achievements boosts morale and motivates team members to strive for better performance.

2. Performance improvement plans (PIPs)

A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a structured approach to help underperforming employees get back on track. HR can implement PIPs to set clear expectations and provide guidance for improvement.

• Set Realistic Goals: Work with the employee to establish achievable performance goals within a specified timeframe. Ensure that these goals are specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART).

• Offer Supportive Resources: Provide the necessary resources, such as training, workshops, or mentoring, to help the employee acquire the skills needed to meet the performance expectations outlined in the PIP.

• Regular Progress Monitoring: Conduct frequent check-ins to review the employee's progress, offer assistance, and discuss any challenges faced during the improvement process.

3. Skill Development and Training

Sometimes, underperformance stems from a lack of skills or knowledge. HR can address this by identifying skill gaps and providing the necessary training and development opportunities.

• Conduct Skill Assessments: Evaluate each employee's skills and competencies to identify areas that need improvement. Use this assessment to tailor training programs to individual needs.

Useful Read: Assessment Centre: The Complete Employers Guide

• Offer Cross-Training Opportunities: Encourage employees to learn new skills by providing cross-training opportunities within the organization. This broadens their knowledge base and enhances their ability to contribute effectively.

• Support Ongoing Learning: Promote a culture of continuous learning by offering access to online courses, workshops, seminars, and other learning resources. Encourage employees to take ownership of their development.

Useful Read: The 5 stages of team development: Strategies for Success

4. Promoting work-life balance

Striking a healthy work-life balance is essential for employee well-being and performance. HR can play a pivotal role in promoting work-life balance among team members.

• Flexible Work Arrangements: Implement flexible work options, such as remote work or flexible hours, to accommodate employees' personal needs and responsibilities.

• Encourage Time Off: Promote the use of vacation days and encourage employees to take time off when needed. This helps prevent burnout and ensures employees return to work refreshed and more productive.

• Lead by Example: HR can set an example by demonstrating a healthy work-life balance and encourage other employees to do the same. Encourage managers to support their team members in maintaining a balanced lifestyle.

5. Regular employee feedback and check-ins

Consistent feedback and check-ins are essential for understanding an employee's performance and providing timely support. HR can facilitate this ongoing feedback process.

• 360-Degree Feedback: Implement a 360-degree feedback system where employees receive feedback from their peers, managers, and subordinates. This comprehensive approach provides a well-rounded view of an employee's performance.

• Conduct Stay Interviews: Regularly conduct stay interviews to understand employees' concerns, aspirations, and challenges. Addressing these concerns proactively can prevent underperformance and improve overall job satisfaction.

• Listen Actively: During check-ins and feedback sessions, practice active listening. Show genuine interest in the employee's perspective and be empathetic to their needs and circumstances.

6. Recognition and positive reinforcement

Recognizing and reinforcing positive behavior can significantly impact employee motivation and performance. HR can implement various strategies to celebrate achievements and boost employee morale.

• Employee Recognition Programs: Establish recognition programs to acknowledge outstanding performance and contributions. This can include awards, certificates, or public recognition during team meetings.

• Peer Recognition: Encourage employees to recognize and appreciate their colleagues' efforts. This peer-to-peer recognition fosters a positive and supportive work culture.

• Tie Recognition to Performance Goals: Connect recognition efforts to performance goals and milestones. This aligns recognition with the organization's objectives and encourages employees to strive for excellence.

7. Job redesign and role realignment

Sometimes, underperformance may result from a mismatch between the employee and their current role. HR can explore job redesign or role realignment to better align employees' skills and interests with their responsibilities.

• Conduct Job Analysis: Analyze the tasks, responsibilities, and skill requirements of each role within the organization. Identify opportunities to modify job descriptions or responsibilities to better suit employees' strengths.

• Offer Job Rotation: Implement job rotation programs where employees can temporarily take on different roles. This provides valuable experiences and helps employees discover roles that suit them better.

• Provide Growth Opportunities: Support employees in pursuing career advancement within the organization. When employees see a clear path for growth, they are more likely to be motivated and perform better.

8. Progressive discipline and termination process

While the primary focus should be on supporting underperforming employees, there may be instances where progressive discipline or termination becomes necessary. HR can follow a fair and consistent approach when dealing with such cases.

• Progressive Discipline: Adopt a progressive approach to address repeated underperformance. Start with verbal warnings or coaching sessions, followed by written warnings, and then formal performance improvement plans if needed.

• Termination as a Last Resort: Termination should be a last resort after all other efforts to support the employee have been exhausted. Ensure the termination process follows company policies and legal guidelines to maintain fairness and respect.

• Offer Exit Interviews: Conduct exit interviews to gather feedback from employees who leave the organization due to underperformance. This feedback can provide valuable insights into areas that may require improvement.

Addressing underperformance as a team: Fostering collaboration and support

In any organization, the success of a team depends on the collective efforts of its members. When an underperforming employee is part of a team, addressing their performance issues becomes a shared responsibility. Instead of singling out the underperforming team member, a collaborative approach can lead to more significant improvements and a positive team dynamic.

1. Open and honest communication

Effective communication is the cornerstone of addressing employee underperformance within a team. Encourage team members to communicate openly and honestly about performance issues, concerns, and challenges. Create a safe space where team members feel comfortable discussing underperformance without fear of judgment or retaliation.

Promote team discussions during regular meetings to address any performance issues collectively. Encourage team members to offer constructive feedback and support to their underperforming colleague. Emphasize the importance of active listening and empathy, enabling the underperforming team member to express their challenges and seek assistance when needed.

2. Shared responsibility for improvement

Rather than leaving the responsibility solely on the underperforming employee, emphasize that addressing underperformance is a team effort. Team members can collaborate to identify areas where the struggling team member may need support or additional resources.

Encourage team members to offer their expertise and experience to help the underperforming team member improve. This collaborative approach fosters a sense of unity and shared purpose within the team, motivating everyone to work together towards achieving common goals.

3. Mentorship and peer support

Implement a mentorship program within the team, pairing underperforming employees with high-performing colleagues. The mentor can provide guidance, share best practices, and offer personalized coaching to help the struggling team member enhance their performance.

Additionally, encourage peer support and teamwork. Team members can pair up on projects or tasks, enabling the underperforming team member to learn from others and receive hands-on assistance. This collaborative learning approach helps build a stronger team bond while addressing performance issues in a supportive manner.

4. Addressing performance issues privately

While fostering teamwork is crucial, it is essential to address individual performance issues privately when necessary. Avoid public shaming or reprimanding of underperforming employees during team meetings, as this can be demoralizing and counterproductive.

Hold private discussions with the underperforming employee to understand their perspective and the challenges they face. Offer support, guidance, and additional resources to help them improve. By addressing performance issues privately, you demonstrate respect for the individual and maintain a positive team atmosphere.

5. Celebrating progress and success

As the underperforming team member makes progress and shows improvement, celebrate their successes openly within the team. Acknowledge the efforts and dedication they put into enhancing their performance.

Team celebrations not only boost the morale of the underperforming employee but also reinforce the collaborative spirit within the team. It sends a message that everyone's contributions are valued, and each team member plays a vital role in the team's success.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

• Easy Employee scheduling
• Clear time-tracking
• Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo

Conclusion

Addressing underperforming employees requires empathy, teamwork, and supportive HR practices.

By fostering a positive work environment, offering skill development, and promoting open communication, organizations can turn underperformance into an opportunity for growth and success.

Embracing the human element in managing underperformance leads to a stronger, more cohesive team and a thriving organization.

Streamlining Employee Performance with Shiftbase

Enhancing employee performance isn't only about rectifying shortcomings but also about leveraging technology for efficient workforce management. That's where Shiftbase steps in. As a comprehensive SaaS solution, Shiftbase provides functionalities like employee scheduling, time tracking, and absence management. This can help your team stay organized, motivated, and productive. Shiftbase allows you to monitor employee performance closely and provide support where necessary, thereby turning potential underperformance situations around.

Intrigued? You can experience the difference Shiftbase can make in your organization with our 14-day free trial. Sign up today and empower your team towards high performance.