Negative References: How To Give One to an Employee

What is a negative reference?

A negative reference occurs when a former employer shares unfavorable information about a former employee with a prospective employer.

This feedback might highlight issues related to the employee’s skills, behavior, or overall job performance. Understanding these references is key to making informed decisions during the hiring process.

Types of negative references

When we talk about negative references, they generally fall into two categories: factual and opinion-based.

• Factual references are based on verifiable events or behaviors. For example, a factual negative reference might note that a job applicant was frequently late or failed to meet their sales targets. These references are straightforward because they are based on clear, observable facts.

• Opinion-based references reflect more subjective views. These might include statements about the former employee’s attitude or team fit. For example, a previous employer might say the job seeker was difficult to work with or lacked commitment. These references can vary significantly depending on personal perceptions and are less black and white.

Common reasons why negative references are given

Employers give negative references for several reasons. Understanding why can help you manage and mitigate the impact on both the job seeker and your hiring process.

• Poor performance: When an employee consistently fails to meet the standards or goals of their job title, a past employer might cite this in a reference.

• Misconduct: Issues like violating company policy, unethical behavior, or legal problems often lead to bad references.

• Attendance issues: Chronic lateness or unexplained absences are common reasons for a former employer to give a negative reference.

• Conflict in the workplace: If an employee had difficulties working with others or was often involved in workplace disputes, these might be highlighted in a reference.

• Lack of professional development: Sometimes, if an employee shows little interest in growth or training, past employers mention this as a negative in terms of not meeting the full potential of the role.

Should you give a negative reference?

Deciding whether to provide a negative reference involves careful consideration of legal and ethical factors.

Legally, you must ensure that any information shared about a former employee is truthful and not misleading. Making false statements that could harm someone’s future employment could lead to legal action. Ethically, it's important to be fair and objective.

While you may have had a bad experience with an employee, consider how sharing this information might impact their career. It’s always good practice to balance negative feedback with any positive aspects of the person’s performance or contributions.

This approach helps potential employers get a fuller picture and supports fair and respectful treatment of job seekers in the hiring process.

Receiving and evaluating negative references

When a potential employer receives a negative reference, it's crucial to handle it with care and diligence. This part of the hiring process can significantly influence your decision-making, so it’s important to ensure that you assess these references thoroughly to make informed and fair employment decisions.

How to solicit comprehensive references?

To gather comprehensive references, start by asking job applicants to provide a detailed reference list that includes a mix of former employers, colleagues, and other professional contacts. This allows you to get a broad perspective on the applicant’s past performance and behavior.

Ensure your reference request form asks specific questions that relate to the job’s requirements, aiming to elicit both positive and negative feedback about relevant skills and experiences.

It's also effective to ask for references that can speak to different aspects of the candidate’s previous job roles, ensuring you receive well-rounded feedback.

Guidelines for interpreting negative comments

When evaluating negative comments, it is essential to focus on gathering accurate information that can be verified. Here are key points to consider:

What to look for in the feedback?

Identify specific instances or patterns that relate directly to job performance and professional behavior. Feedback that details particular situations or behaviors is more valuable than vague or general comments. It’s crucial to discern between feedback on professional capabilities versus personal dislikes.

How to distinguish between constructive criticism and spite?

Constructive criticism typically offers details and examples and may even suggest areas for improvement, reflecting good faith on the part of the referee.

In contrast, comments that lack specifics or are emotionally charged may indicate personal bias or spite. These require careful interpretation and further investigation to avoid unfair judgments.

Verifying the accuracy of a negative reference

To verify the accuracy of a negative reference, consider these steps:

• Contact the reference provider directly and ask for specific examples or further details to substantiate their comments.

• Check the employment dates and job titles provided by the reference to ensure they align with the candidate’s resume.

• If available, consult with other references or former employers to see if their feedback corroborates or contradicts the negative reference.

• If inconsistencies arise, discuss them with the candidate to hear their side of the story, providing an opportunity to clarify or counter the feedback.

Legal obligations and rights concerning reference checks

Employers must navigate federal and state laws carefully during the reference check process:

• Accurate information and good faith: Employers have a legal duty to provide accurate information and act in good faith when giving or receiving references. Misrepresentation can lead to defamation cases or employment tribunal claims.

• Qualified immunity: Many employers are protected under qualified immunity when providing references, as long as they do not intentionally provide false information.

• Employer obligations: When conducting reference checks, ensure compliance with applicable laws, which may govern what can be asked and disclosed. Always strive to be impartial and objective to avoid any legal implications.

• Employee rights: Job seekers are protected from discriminatory practices and have the right to contest information they believe to be false or misleading. They may also pursue legal action if they feel their reference was maliciously unfavorable.

Properly handling negative references is not just about filtering bad candidates; it’s about respecting the legal framework, ensuring fair treatment for all involved, and ultimately making the best hiring decisions for your organization.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

• Easy Employee scheduling
• Clear time-tracking
• Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo

Conclusion

Effectively managing a bad reference requires careful consideration from human resources professionals and recruiting employers alike.

Navigating the sensitive information about former employees demands not only a strategic approach but also adherence to federal laws to avoid potential legal complications, such as employment tribunal claims.

When an employer refuses a job applicant based on a negative reference, it is critical to ensure that all actions are grounded in fairness and legality. By fostering a meticulous and ethical approach to reference checks, organizations can make informed hiring decisions that benefit both the company and its potential new members.