Clopening Shifts and Clopening Laws Explained: A Guide

What is a clopen shift?

A clopen shift or clopening shifts is a scheduling practice where an employee is assigned to close the workplace at night and return shortly after to open it the next morning. This results in minimal time between shifts, often leading to inadequate rest for the employee. The term "clopening" combines "closing" and "opening" to describe this back-to-back shift arrangement.

Example of a Clopening Shift:

Consider a barista at a coffee shop:

Shift Type	Shift Timing	Duration
Closing Shift	5:00 PM – 11:30 PM	6.5 hours
Opening Shift	4:30 AM – 10:30 AM	6 hours

In this scenario, the barista finishes the closing shift at 11:30 PM and is scheduled to start the opening shift at 4:30 AM the next day. This provides a rest period of only 5 hours between shifts, during which the employee must commute home, sleep, and return to work, leading to insufficient rest and potential fatigue.

Clopening shifts are prevalent in industries with extended operating hours or 24/7 services, such as:

• Retail Stores
• Restaurants and Bars
• Hotels and Hospitality Services
• Convenience Stores
• Healthcare Facilities

While clopening shifts can offer scheduling flexibility for employers, they often pose challenges for employees, including sleep deprivation, increased stress, and a disrupted work-life balance.

Employers are encouraged to consider these factors when designing work schedules to promote employee well-being and maintain operational efficiency.

Why do businesses use clopening shifts?

Businesses may implement clopening shifts—where an employee closes the establishment at night and returns to open it the next morning—for several operational reasons:

Staffing flexibility:

• Coverage During Peak Hours: In industries with fluctuating customer demand, such as retail and hospitality, clopening shifts can help ensure that experienced staff are present during both the late-night closing and early-morning opening periods.
  
  
• Maximizing Limited Staff: Small businesses or those facing staffing shortages might schedule clopening shifts to maintain operational continuity without hiring additional employees.

2. Cost management:

• Reduced Training Expenses: Assigning clopening shifts to seasoned employees can minimise the need for extensive training, as these workers are already familiar with both opening and closing procedures.
  
  
• Labor Cost Optimisation: By scheduling the same employees for consecutive shifts, businesses might reduce the total number of staff hours required, potentially leading to lower labor costs.

Simplified scheduling:

• Managerial Convenience: Especially in establishments with extended operating hours, creating schedules that include clopening shifts can be more straightforward for managers, ensuring that trusted employees handle critical opening and closing tasks.
  
  
• Use of Scheduling Algorithms: Some businesses utilise automated scheduling systems that, without proper configuration, may inadvertently assign clopening shifts to employees.

Employee availability:

• Voluntary Overtime: Certain employees may opt for clopening shifts to increase their earnings through overtime pay, particularly if they have limited availability during standard hours.
  
  
• Personal Preferences: Some staff members might prefer consecutive shifts to cluster their working hours, allowing for extended periods of personal time on subsequent days.

While clopening shifts can offer operational benefits, it's crucial for employers to balance these advantages with the potential impact on employee well-being.

Regularly scheduling clopening shifts can lead to fatigue, decreased morale, and increased turnover.

Implementing fair scheduling practices and ensuring adequate rest periods between shifts can help mitigate these negative effects.

The negative impact of clopening shifts

Clopening shifts—where an employee closes the workplace at night and returns to open it the next morning—can have significant repercussions for both employees and businesses.

Impact on employees:

❌Sleep Deprivation and Health Issues:

• Inadequate Rest: The short interval between closing and opening shifts often deprives employees of sufficient sleep, leading to chronic fatigue.
• Health Risks: Persistent sleep deprivation is linked to serious health problems, including heart disease, high blood pressure, diabetes, and obesity.

❌Work-Life Balance Disruption:

• Personal Life Interference: Irregular hours make it challenging for employees to manage personal responsibilities, such as childcare and family time, leading to increased stress and dissatisfaction.

❌Increased Stress and Burnout:

• Mental Strain: The pressure of consecutive shifts with minimal rest can elevate stress levels, contributing to burnout and decreased job satisfaction.

Impact on businesses:

❌Decreased Productivity:

• Performance Decline: Fatigued employees are more prone to errors and slower task completion, adversely affecting overall productivity.

❌Higher Turnover Rates:

• Employee Retention Challenges: The strain of clopening shifts can lead to increased employee turnover, resulting in higher recruitment and training costs.

❌Negative Customer Experience:

• Service Quality Impact: Exhausted employees may provide subpar customer service, potentially damaging the business's reputation and customer loyalty.

Addressing the challenges posed by clopening shifts is crucial for maintaining a healthy workforce and ensuring business success.

Implementing fair scheduling practices, ensuring adequate rest periods, and considering employee well-being can mitigate these negative impacts.

Are clopening shifts legal?

Clopening shifts are generally legal in many jurisdictions. However, several regions have implemented regulations to address the potential negative impacts of such scheduling practices.

United states:

• Federal Law: There are no federal regulations explicitly prohibiting clopening shifts. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) mandates minimum wage and overtime pay but does not govern the scheduling of shifts or required rest periods between them.

• State and Local Laws: Some states and municipalities have enacted laws to mitigate the effects of clopening shifts:

  • New York City: The Fair Workweek Law requires fast-food employers to provide a minimum of 11 hours between shifts unless the employee consents in writing and receives a $100 premium.

  • Oregon: The Fair Workweek Act mandates a minimum 10-hour rest period between shifts. If an employee works with less than the required rest, they are entitled to time-and-a-half pay for the hours worked during the insufficient rest period.

  • Seattle: Similar to Oregon, Seattle's Secure Scheduling Ordinance requires a 10-hour rest period between shifts, with additional compensation if this rest period is not honored.

United kingdom:

In the UK, while there are no specific laws addressing clopening shifts, the Working Time Regulations 1998 stipulate that workers are entitled to:

• Daily Rest: A minimum of 11 consecutive hours of rest in any 24-hour period.

• Weekly Rest: At least 24 hours of uninterrupted rest per week or 48 hours per fortnight.

These provisions effectively limit the feasibility of clopening shifts, as scheduling such shifts would likely violate the required rest periods.

Employer considerations:

Even in areas without specific regulations, it's prudent for employers to consider the potential negative impacts of clopening shifts on employee well-being, productivity, and retention.

Implementing fair scheduling practices and ensuring adequate rest between shifts can foster a healthier work environment and may preemptively address potential future regulatory changes.

In summary, while clopening shifts are not universally prohibited, various jurisdictions have implemented laws to regulate them, aiming to protect employee health and well-being.

Employers should stay informed about local labor laws and consider adopting scheduling practices that promote sufficient rest between shifts.

What are clopening laws?

Clopening laws are regulations designed to address the practice of scheduling employees to work consecutive closing and opening shifts with minimal rest in between. These laws aim to protect workers' health and well-being by ensuring they receive adequate rest periods between shifts.

Key provisions of clopening laws:

Mandatory Rest Periods:

• Minimum Hours Between Shifts: Many jurisdictions require employers to provide a specified minimum number of hours between the end of one shift and the start of the next. For example, in New York City, fast-food employers must ensure an 11-hour gap between shifts unless the employee consents in writing and receives a $100 premium.

Employee Consent and Compensation:

• Written Agreement: In certain areas, if an employer needs to schedule shifts with less than the mandated rest period, they must obtain the employee's written consent.
  
  
• Premium Pay: Employees agreeing to shortened rest periods are often entitled to additional compensation. For instance, in Seattle and Oregon, if an employee consents to a rest period of fewer than 10 hours between shifts, they must be compensated at one and a half times their regular pay rate for the hours worked during the insufficient rest period.

Predictive Scheduling Requirements:

• Advance Notice: Some jurisdictions mandate that employers provide employees with their work schedules a certain number of days in advance. This practice, known as predictive scheduling, helps employees plan their personal lives and reduces the likelihood of clopening shifts. For example, Oregon's Fair Workweek Act requires employers to provide written work schedules at least seven days in advance.

Industries commonly affected:

Clopening laws primarily impact industries with extended operating hours, such as:

• Retail
• Hospitality
• Food Service

These sectors often require employees to work late-night closing shifts followed by early-morning opening shifts, making them the focus of clopening regulations.

Employer responsibilities:

To comply with clopening laws, employers should:

• Review Local Regulations: Labor laws can vary by jurisdiction; it's essential to understand and adhere to local requirements.
• Implement Fair Scheduling Practices: Ensure that work schedules allow for adequate rest periods between shifts.
• Obtain Necessary Consents: If reduced rest periods are unavoidable, secure written consent from employees and provide any required premium pay.
• Maintain Accurate Records: Keep detailed records of work schedules, employee consents, and compensation to demonstrate compliance with labor laws.

By adhering to clopening laws, employers can promote a healthier work environment, enhance employee satisfaction, and reduce the risk of legal penalties associated with non-compliance.

How do we avoid clopening shifts?

Avoiding clopening shifts—where an employee closes the workplace at night and returns to open it the next morning—is essential for maintaining employee well-being and operational efficiency. Here are strategies employers and managers can implement to prevent such scheduling practices:

❇️ Implement advanced scheduling tools:

• Utilise Scheduling Software: Employ software solutions that allow you to set parameters preventing back-to-back closing and opening shifts. These tools can automate scheduling, ensuring compliance with rest period policies and reducing manual errors.

❇️ Foster open communication:

• Gather Employee Input: Engage with employees to understand their scheduling preferences and constraints. Regular feedback can help create schedules that accommodate both operational needs and employee well-being.

❇️ Provide schedules in advance:

• Advance Notice: Issuing work schedules well ahead of time allows employees to plan accordingly, reducing stress and the likelihood of conflicts. Aim to provide schedules at least two weeks in advance.

❇️ Cross-train employees:

• Enhance Workforce Flexibility: Training employees in multiple roles increases scheduling flexibility, enabling managers to distribute shifts more evenly and avoid over-reliance on specific staff for opening or closing duties.

❇️ Hire additional staff:

• Expand the Team: Increasing the number of employees can alleviate the need for clopening shifts by distributing workloads more evenly, ensuring adequate rest periods for all staff members.

❇️ Monitor and adjust scheduling practices:

• Regular Review: Continuously assess scheduling patterns to identify and rectify any instances of clopening shifts. Adjust practices as needed to align with both employee well-being and business requirements.

By implementing these strategies, employers can create a more sustainable and employee-friendly work environment, leading to improved morale, reduced turnover, and enhanced operational efficiency.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

• Easy Employee scheduling
• Clear time-tracking
• Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo

Best practices for employers and HR professionals

To address the challenges posed by clopening shifts and create a more employee-friendly work environment, consider adopting these best practices:

• Implement fair scheduling policies: Develop scheduling policies that distribute clopening shifts fairly among employees, considering their preferences and availability.

• Provide adequate notice: Give employees ample notice before assigning clopening shifts, allowing them to plan and adjust their routines accordingly.

• Use scheduling software: Leverage scheduling software to optimize shifts, prevent excessive clopening assignments, and ensure compliance with labor laws.

• Offer flexible scheduling: Introduce flexible scheduling options, such as split shifts or longer breaks between shifts, to provide employees with opportunities for rest.

• Promote open communication: Encourage employees to communicate their scheduling preferences and concerns, fostering a collaborative approach to scheduling decisions.

• Monitor workload: Regularly assess staffing needs to avoid overburdening employees with consecutive closing and opening shifts during busy periods.

Useful Read: The Employer's Guide to Implementing Workload Balance

By embracing these best practices, employers and HR professionals can improve employee satisfaction, enhance business performance, and create a more balanced work-life experience.

Conclusion

By recognizing the challenges posed to hourly employees by this scheduling practice and implementing fair, employee-centered solutions, employers can improve employee well-being, boost morale, and elevate overall business performance.

Striking the right balance between operational demands and the welfare of the workforce not only contributes to a more harmonious workplace but also enhances the long-term success of both the employer and the business as a whole.

Addressing Clopening Shifts with Shiftbase

Clopening shifts can challenge the well-being and efficiency of employees, making it crucial for businesses to manage such shifts effectively.

Shiftbase emerges as a beacon for businesses grappling with workforce management issues like this. Its adept employee scheduling capabilities ensure that such consecutive shifts are minimized, while the time tracking feature allows for precise monitoring of working hours.

Additionally, the absence management tool provides insights into leave patterns, further optimizing your scheduling. Navigate the challenges of clopening shifts and more with Shiftbase.

Try our software free for 14 days and witness the transformation in your workforce management!