Is Skills Based Hiring Worth Your While? The Exploration Guide

Forget the obsession with degrees—skills-based hiring is flipping the script by valuing what candidates can actually do. By focusing on demonstrated skills and real-world experience, employers can tackle the skills gap and adapt to the growing demands of the job market. It's about finding talent that delivers, not just diplomas.

So what is skills-based hiring approach?

Skills-based hiring is all about prioritizing what candidates can actually do rather than the college degree they hold. This approach focuses on practical skills, whether gained through experience, training, or self-learning, to better predict success in a role.

Unlike traditional hiring that leans heavily on formal education, skills-based hiring evaluates candidates based on tangible competencies like problem-solving, creativity, and adaptability. By focusing on a person’s real-world abilities, employers can identify candidates with the potential to excel, while also addressing the growing skills gap in the job market.

This hiring method emphasizes measurable capabilities over credentials, ensuring a more inclusive process that values diverse experiences. It’s a shift that enables businesses to hire and promote workers based on skill, leading to stronger teams and improved business performance.

The shift toward skills-based hiring practices

Many employers are shifting toward skills-based hiring practices as an alternative to traditional degree requirements. Several factors are driving the shift toward this new hiring model. This shift is largely driven by the diminishing necessity of college degrees for many job roles, as employers adopt skills-based hiring practices to broaden their talent pools and foster diversity in the workplace.

Skills gap and workforce challenges

A study by the Burning Glass Institute shows that nearly 63% of job postings in the US still require a four-year degree, even though many of these roles could be effectively filled by candidates without one. This practice unnecessarily shrinks the labor pool and excludes millions of skilled individuals.

On the other hand, organizations that adopt skills-based hiring practices and eliminate four-year degree requirements have seen remarkable improvements. Research from Boston Consulting Group reveals that companies implementing this approach can expand their talent pool by 20% or more, ensuring a broader range of candidates and perspectives.

Improved performance and retention

Data also indicates that employees hired through skills-based practices are 40% more likely to stay with their employer for three years or more. This increased retention not only reduces hiring costs but also boosts organizational stability and morale.

Moreover, businesses that prioritize skills over degrees often report enhanced productivity and innovation. By diversifying candidate pools, companies can bring in a variety of perspectives and experiences, enabling them to better navigate and succeed in a dynamic business environment. This hiring style allows them to identify talent capable of tackling real-world challenges with a practical, hands-on approach.

Real-world success stories

The shift toward skills-first hiring is supported by leading organizations. For example, IBM has adopted a “skills-first” mindset to address the growing demand for tech talent. By focusing on demonstrable abilities rather than formal education, IBM is helping close the skills gap while providing well-paying jobs to individuals from diverse backgrounds.

Similarly, GE Appliances integrates skills-based hiring in its recruitment process. By evaluating technical skills directly, they ensure that new hires have the expertise required to excel in roles like CNC machining or robotics. This approach not only strengthens their workforce but also promotes long-term employee satisfaction. By embracing a diverse group of candidates, GE Appliances benefits from a wider range of experiences and skills, which enhances innovation and productivity.

Skills-Based Hiring Job Description Template

Download now

The role of education and degrees

The relevance of traditional educational qualifications is being challenged as skills-based hiring gains traction. While degrees have long been a standard measure of competence, they may no longer be the most reliable indicator of job readiness in many industries.

The limitations of degrees in hiring

• Exclusion of Qualified Candidates: Requiring degrees can eliminate skilled individuals who gained expertise through alternative pathways like apprenticeships, certifications, or self-learning. The commerce release skills first initiative by the U.S. Departments of Labor and Commerce promotes skills-first hiring practices through a published guide, educating employers on the benefits of hiring based on skills and knowledge rather than traditional degree requirements.
• Mismatch with Job Requirements: Many roles prioritize hands-on experience and specific skills that traditional education doesn’t always provide.
• Outdated Knowledge: In rapidly evolving fields like tech, degree curricula often lag behind industry needs.

The evolving role of education

• Complementing Skills: Degrees can still play a role when combined with clear demonstrations of relevant skills. Adopting a skills-first approach serves as a competitive advantage for companies in attracting and retaining top talent. Candidates hired based on their skills tend to be more engaged and likely to remain with the company compared to those hired solely based on degree qualifications.
• Focus on Lifelong Learning: Employers are increasingly valuing continuous education and certifications over static academic achievements.
• Soft Skills Insight: While degrees sometimes reflect soft skills like commitment and communication, these can now be assessed through alternative methods like behavioral interviews.

Finding the balance

In talent acquisition, education still has its place, but as one piece of a larger puzzle. By valuing degrees alongside measurable skills, employers can create a more inclusive and effective hiring process that identifies the best fit for each role.

Employee scheduling and Time-tracking software!

• Easy Employee scheduling
• Clear time-tracking
• Simple absence management

Try for free Request a demo

The impact of skills-based hiring on employers

Skills-based hiring offers a range of benefits that are hard to ignore. Here’s how it positively impacts employers:

• Broader Talent Pool: By focusing on skills instead of degrees, employers can access a wider range of candidates, including those from non-traditional backgrounds.
• Improved Job Performance: Matching candidates’ skills directly to job requirements leads to better performance and productivity.
• Increased Retention: Employees hired for their competencies are 40% more likely to stay with their organization for three years or more, reducing turnover and related costs.
• Enhanced Diversity and Inclusion: This approach naturally encourages a more diverse workforce by valuing varied experiences and perspectives.
• Cost Efficiency: Skills-based hiring reduces mismatches, lowering the time and cost spent on rehiring and retraining.
• Stronger Teams: Hiring based on measurable skills results in teams that are more effective and aligned with business goals.

While skills-based hiring brings numerous advantages, there are challenges to consider when implementing this approach. One hurdle is overcoming the deeply ingrained belief that degrees are synonymous with essential skills. Some employers still rely on degrees as a proxy for soft skills, such as teamwork, communication, and prioritization. Addressing this bias and skills gap requires a shift in mindset and an increased focus on assessing and valuing these soft skills through alternative methods, such as behavioural interviews or skills assessments.

Creating a balanced hiring process is another consideration. While skills are paramount, other factors, such as cultural fit and organizational values, remain important. Striking the right balance between skills and cultural fit ensures that organizations can build cohesive and high-performing teams.

So are skills first hiring practices worth it?

Absolutely, and here’s why skills-first hiring is a game-changer for businesses:

• Proven Business Benefits: Research from Boston Consulting Group shows that companies using skills-based hiring can expand their talent pool by 20% and reduce turnover by 40%. This means not only hiring faster but also building teams that stick around longer.
• Diverse and Inclusive Workplaces: By focusing on skills, employers naturally open the door to candidates from all walks of life, including those who might not have traditional degrees but bring valuable expertise.
• Cost Savings: Skills-based hiring reduces mismatches, saving companies money on training, rehiring, and lost productivity.
• Boosted Innovation and Productivity: Employees hired for their skills are better equipped to solve real-world challenges and contribute to business performance from day one.

The numbers and real-world examples don’t lie—adopting skills-first hiring practices is a smart move for employers looking to stay ahead and build resilient teams. The U.S. Department of Labor has even developed a new Skills-First Hiring Starter Kit, a hiring guide to help employers adopt these practices effectively.

Implementation strategies for skills first hiring practices

Making the shift to skills-based hiring requires a clear plan and the right tools. Below are practical strategies to implement this approach successfully.

Update job descriptions

• Focus on specific skills and competencies needed for the role.
• Remove unnecessary degree requirements unless absolutely essential.
• Use inclusive language to attract a broader and more diverse pool of candidates.

Use skills assessments

• Implement tools like online skills tests or real-world task evaluations.
• Incorporate hands-on demonstrations during the interview process.
• Use standardized scoring to fairly compare candidates’ abilities.

Train hiring teams

• Educate recruiters and hiring managers about the benefits of skills-based hiring.
• Offer training on identifying and evaluating measurable competencies.
• Ensure a consistent approach to assessing both technical and soft skills.

Leverage technology

• Use AI-powered platforms to analyze resumes for relevant skills.
• Integrate applicant tracking systems to streamline recruitment.
• Explore virtual simulation tools to assess job-specific abilities.

Track and measure success

• Collect data on employee performance and retention rates post-hire.
• Regularly review and refine the hiring process based on outcomes.
• Use feedback from candidates and hiring teams to improve continuously.

To support this transition, there are various resources available, including a comprehensive guide to help employers adopt skills-first hiring practices.

Skills-Based Hiring Job Description Template

Download now