The Shift Preference Guide: How to Match Shifts with Employee Needs

Figuring out the perfect shift schedule is like trying to solve a puzzle—one that affects job satisfaction, productivity, and even work-life balance. But let’s face it: not everyone’s on the same page when it comes to shift preferences. While some employees thrive in a morning shift, others feel more energized during the midnight shift, night shifts, or even the late afternoon.

As an employer or manager, understanding these shift preferences isn’t just about filling shift hours or maintaining business operations; it’s about accommodating employee shift preferences in a way that benefits the entire organization. Employees have their own individual productivity cycles, family commitments, and even health considerations that influence what shift they’d prefer to work.

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about shift preferences. From exploring the different types of shifts and factors that affect shift workers’ choices to practical ways for managers to balance employee shift preferences with business needs, we’ve got it covered. By the end, you’ll have a clear strategy for managing employee preferences effectively—and a happier, more engaged team as a result.

The primary types of shifts to consider

When it comes to structuring shift hours, not all shifts are created equal. From morning shifts to the graveyard shift, each brings unique demands and benefits for both employees and the organization.

Morning and day shifts

The morning shift, typically running from around 8 AM to 4 PM, and the day shift, spanning the regular 9-to-5 hours, are often the most popular. Many employees prefer these shifts because they align with natural daylight, offering a more structured routine. Employees working these shifts often enjoy better work-life balance, making it ideal for those who thrive on consistency.

• Ideal Traits: Early risers and employees who enjoy having evenings free often excel on the morning shift or first shift. This setup generally suits those who prefer a clear separation between work and personal time.

• Productivity Perks: Employees on the day shift often experience heightened productivity, aligning with natural energy peaks and benefiting from maximum daylight. This can reduce the need for overtime pay by helping employees get through their workload within regular hours.

• Business Benefits: Organizations benefit from high visibility during these hours, as other HR systems and departments are typically operating at the same time, which makes coordination easier and increases efficiency.

Evening and night shifts

Evening shifts, often covering late afternoon into early night (4 PM to midnight), and night shifts, which typically start around midnight and run until early morning, attract a different kind of worker. The midnight shift, also known as the graveyard shift or third shift, is less common but essential in industries like healthcare, security, and manufacturing that require round-the-clock coverage.

• Ideal Traits: Employees with a natural affinity for quieter work environments, or those who are “night owls,” can thrive in the night shift. This shift often works well for people who need daytime availability or prefer fewer workplace interactions.

• Productivity and Performance: Working night shifts allows for fewer distractions, helping shift workers focus. However, employers should note that night shifts can affect work-life balance and physical health, so offering support for employee well-being is key.

• Business Needs: For companies needing 24/7 operations, night shifts are essential. Positions in healthcare, security, and customer support often require staffing around the clock, and night shifts help maintain continuity. These shifts can also lead to wage differentials, which might make them more appealing to some employees.

Rotational and split shifts

Rotational shifts and split shifts offer flexibility for businesses and employees but require a bit more coordination. Rotational shifts, where employees cycle through different shifts over a set period, can help fill positions with varied shift hours while keeping employees fresh. Split shifts, where an employee’s working hours are divided into two or more segments in one day, are common in industries needing coverage at peak hours, like customer service or food service.

• Flexibility Benefits: Rotational and split shifts cater to industries needing flexibility. Rotational shifts allow employers to cover different times without committing specific employees to one shift indefinitely. Split shifts help companies match peak demands, such as busy morning and late afternoon periods, without adding extra staffing.

• Productivity Pros and Cons: Rotational shifts can keep things fresh for employees but may impact work-life balance if not managed well. Split shifts can be challenging for those who prefer a continuous work block, as breaking the day into sections might disrupt productivity for some employees.

• Staff Requirements: These shifts work well for organizations that operate outside traditional hours, like hospitality, healthcare, or retail. However, managers need to be aware of the unique requirements these shifts place on employee preferences and ensure schedules align with individual availability for higher job satisfaction.

By offering various types of shifts, employers can accommodate employee shift preferences while ensuring business needs are met effectively.

Factors influencing shift preferences

Employees’ shift preferences often depend on a blend of personal, financial, and career-related factors. Let’s look at the key influences behind why employees prefer certain shift hours.

Individual productivity cycles

Every employee has unique energy peaks and lows throughout the day, impacting which shift hours they perform best in. Some employees are naturally more alert in the early hours, making a morning shift or day shift a better fit, while others hit their stride during the evening or late at night, making them ideal for night shifts or the midnight shift.

Energy Cycles: Known as circadian rhythms, these natural energy cycles influence how well employees perform on different shifts.

Matching Shifts to Energy Levels: When employees’ productivity aligns with their shift, they tend to experience higher job satisfaction and less fatigue. A night owl, for example, might feel more productive on a graveyard shift than on a first shift that starts early in the morning.

Impact on Business: By understanding employee preferences in relation to their natural productivity, managers can create schedules that maximize productivity across all shifts.

Health, sleep, and work-life balance

Shift hours have a direct impact on physical and mental health. Working night shifts or the graveyard shift can interfere with sleep patterns and, over time, even affect health outcomes. Balancing shift schedules with employees’ personal lives is key to maintaining job satisfaction and well-being.

Sleep and Health Effects: Long hours or irregular shift schedules can disrupt sleep, leading to issues like fatigue and reduced productivity. Employees on night shifts, for instance, may need extra time to adjust their sleep schedule.

Work-Life Balance: Employees with families often prefer a day shift or first shift since it’s easier to coordinate with school hours and social schedules. Flexible shifts, like split shifts, allow some employees to better manage their responsibilities outside of work.

Supporting Well-being: Companies can enhance job satisfaction by offering shift flexibility and supporting employees’ mental and physical health through schedule preferences that align with their personal lives.

Career progression opportunities

Visibility and networking opportunities differ across shifts, affecting career progression for shift workers. Employees on day shifts are often more visible to upper management, which can influence growth opportunities. However, with the right policies, all employees can have fair access to career advancement.

Day vs. Night Shifts: Day shifts naturally offer more chances for employees to interact with managers and other departments, which can be an advantage for career development. On the other hand, those on night shifts or the midnight shift might have fewer opportunities to showcase their skills.

Fair Career Development: Employers can create fair career paths by ensuring employees on all shifts receive recognition for their work. By aligning responsibilities and scheduling tasks that allow for employee visibility, companies can balance career progression across different shifts.

Networking Benefits: While employees on a morning shift may enjoy more direct interaction, rotational shifts offer a balanced approach, allowing employees to gain visibility at different times.

Financial considerations

Wage differentials, especially for less popular shifts, play a significant role in employee preferences. Offering additional pay for night shifts, third shifts, or split shifts can attract employees willing to adjust their schedule.

Incentives for Night and Rotational Shifts: Employers often offer higher wages for night shifts and the graveyard shift, making these options more attractive. This helps fill less desirable shifts while giving employees a financial boost.

Influence on Shift Choice: For employees considering schedule preferences, the potential for overtime pay or shift differentials can make a particular shift more appealing. Financial incentives also support job satisfaction by compensating employees for the challenges that come with non-traditional hours.

Managing Financial Incentives: Organizations and HR departments can use wage differentials strategically, ensuring all shift hours are adequately covered while aligning with employee preferences.

These factors are essential in understanding and accommodating employee shift preferences, ensuring a more satisfied, productive workforce while balancing business needs.

Managing shift preferences for a balanced team

Creating a balanced team that accommodates employee shift preferences doesn’t have to be a guessing game. With the right tools and approach, you can align employee preferences with business needs effectively.

Gathering employee input effectively

To manage shift schedules that truly work, it’s essential to gather feedback directly from employees. Use survey tools or conduct short meetings to gather insights into employee preferences, which will help you understand who prefers which shift hours and why.

• Surveys: Simple online surveys or pulse check tools can capture employee preferences quickly, giving you insights into who might prefer the morning shift, night shift, or split shifts.

• Meetings: Host occasional team meetings to discuss shift preferences and get direct input. Encourage employees to voice any preferences or flexibility they have with shift hours.

• Data Analysis: Gather data from survey responses to analyze common trends. For instance, you might find a preference for the second shift among employees who need flexibility for childcare.

By collecting input regularly, you can create shift schedules that suit both employee needs and the demands of the business.

Using scheduling software to optimize shift matching

When it comes to aligning employee shift preferences with your scheduling needs, scheduling software like Shiftbase is a powerful tool. Scheduling software allows HR departments to manage shift allocations efficiently, balancing employee preferences with business requirements.

• Balancing Needs and Preferences: Tools like Shiftbase make it easy to assign shifts based on employee availability and preferences. It’s especially helpful when you need to fill less popular shifts like the midnight shift or graveyard shift without overburdening any one team member.

• Integration with Other HR Systems: Shiftbase and other scheduling software can sync with HR systems, ensuring that shift workers’ preferences, availability, and shift hours are all up-to-date. This integration streamlines the scheduling process, reducing errors.

• Adapting to Changes: If employees need to swap shifts due to changes in their availability, scheduling software can simplify the process, ensuring a smooth adjustment that respects both the employee's preference and the company's requirements.

Using scheduling software not only saves time for HR but also provides employees with more control over their schedules.

Open communication and flexibility

Transparent shift-swapping guidelines and open communication help manage employee shift preferences smoothly. A flexible approach allows employees to adjust shifts without compromising the business's needs or causing friction among the team.

• Shift-Swapping Guidelines: Create clear rules for trading shifts, whether it's for the morning shift, third shift, or split shifts. Define the responsibilities of both employees and managers when a shift trade is requested.

• Handling Requests Fairly: Encourage employees to communicate openly with managers about any preference changes. This ensures fairness when handling shift changes and reduces the chance of favoritism.

• Flexibility for Employee Satisfaction: Flexibility fosters job satisfaction by allowing employees to adjust shifts when needed, helping to align work schedules with personal commitments.

Open communication about shift preferences and the ability to make adjustments can enhance employee engagement and retention.

Evaluating and iterating scheduling models

Creating an ideal shift schedule is an ongoing process. Regularly evaluating and refining your scheduling model helps keep it aligned with the changing needs of both employees and the organization.

• Schedule Review: Regularly review your scheduling practices, especially if you’re managing split shifts, rotational shifts, or non-traditional hours. Make sure they’re meeting productivity goals and employee satisfaction.

• Feedback Loop: After implementing a new schedule, gather feedback from employees to understand what’s working and what isn’t. Pay attention to employee well-being, as different shifts can impact productivity and health differently.

• Continuous Improvement: Use data from scheduling software to track patterns and make data-driven adjustments to shift assignments. By iterating on your scheduling model, you can keep improving the balance between employee preferences and business needs.

Managing shift preferences with these strategies can help create a balanced, productive team while accommodating employee needs in a fair and transparent way.

Your work schedule in one central place!

• Create rosters quickly
• Insight into labor costs
• Access anywhere via the app

Try for free Request a demo

Optimize shift preferences effortlessly with Shiftbase

Managing employee shift preferences is easier with the right tools in place. Shiftbase, a SaaS solution for workforce management, offers essential features like employee scheduling, time tracking, and absence management. By aligning employee preferences with business needs, Shiftbase helps create fair, balanced schedules that boost productivity and job satisfaction. Whether you’re managing a morning shift or the night shift, Shiftbase gives you more control over every shift.

Ready to see how Shiftbase can improve your employee shift preferences? Try it free for 14 days here.